The 1869 Indian Head Penny has a mintage of only 6,420,000 coins & includes a 9 over 9 overdate variety that commands much higher prices.

1869 Indian Head Cent - Fine

1869 Indian Head Cent - Fine

 -
 $179.00
$190.00		 1h 19m
1869 Indian Head Cent Good (Key Date)

1869 Indian Head Cent Good (Key Date)

 -
 $80.00
$84.00		 5h 23m
1869 9 OVER 9 INDIAN HEAD SMALL CENT AT NO RESERVE

1869 9 OVER 9 INDIAN HEAD SMALL CENT AT NO RESERVE

 2
 $127.49
 5h 28m
1869 United States indian head penny old us coin

1869 United States indian head penny old us coin

6
 $6.55
 7h 50m
1869 key date Indian Head cent, nice solid coin

1869 key date Indian Head cent, nice solid coin

 8
 $17.50
 8h 15m
1869 69 Cent, G-VG - Good Date- Original- NO RES

1869 69 Cent, G-VG - Good Date- Original- NO RES

 -
 $98.00
$118.00		 8h 52m
1869 Indian Cent ANACS EF-40 (Tough date!)

1869 Indian Cent ANACS EF-40 (Tough date!)

 -
 $499.99
 8h 52m
1869 Indian Head Penny - NICE KEY DATE!!!

1869 Indian Head Penny - NICE KEY DATE!!!

 7
 $20.51
 9h 16m
1869 INDIAN HEAD PENNY

1869 INDIAN HEAD PENNY

 -
 $19.95
 1d 3h 22m
1869 US MINT INDIAN HEAD SMALL CENT FULL RIM

1869 US MINT INDIAN HEAD SMALL CENT FULL RIM

 -
 $89.99
 1d 5h 25m
1869 Indian Head Cent Clear Date Good

1869 Indian Head Cent Clear Date Good

 -
 $67.95
 1d 7h 5m
Very Nice 1869 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

Very Nice 1869 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

 5
 $12.75
 1d 7h 36m
1869 9 XF AU Indian Head cent Nice Coin N0708

1869 9 XF AU Indian Head cent Nice Coin N0708

 -
 $860.00
$875.00		 1d 7h 43m
Replica 1869 Indian Head penny

Replica 1869 Indian Head penny

 -
 $0.10
 1d 7h 48m
1869 Indian Head Penny - Key Date One Cent US Coin

1869 Indian Head Penny - Key Date One Cent US Coin

 6
 $7.25
 1d 9h 44m
1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT NICE DETAILS KEY DATE

1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT NICE DETAILS KEY DATE

 6
 $17.25
 1d 10h 5m
1869 8 Indian Cent G Interesting Variety

1869 8 Indian Cent G Interesting Variety

 2
 $5.60
 1d 22h 21m
Indian Cent Set Missing 1856 1869 1869 69 1878 in Album

Indian Cent Set Missing 1856 1869 1869 69 1878 in Album

 -
 $1,350.00
$1,425.00		 2d 11m
1869 INDIAN CENT - Original & Uncleaned Coin

1869 INDIAN CENT - Original & Uncleaned Coin

 -
 $45.00
 2d 54m
1869 Beauty, VG+ Indian Head, Take a Look, RARE

1869 Beauty, VG+ Indian Head, Take a Look, RARE

 eBay Giving Works 2
 $41.23
 2d 4h 13m
1869 Indian Head Cent ANACS XF Sharp Details

1869 Indian Head Cent ANACS XF Sharp Details

 $459.95 2d 5h 23m
Very Nice 1869 Indian Head Cent FREE S H!!

Very Nice 1869 Indian Head Cent FREE S H!!

 4
 $11.50
 2d 7h 58m
Replica 1869 9 over 9 Indian head cents COPY

Replica 1869 9 over 9 Indian head cents COPY

 -
 $0.10
 2d 8h 23m
Replica 1869 Indian head cents COPY

Replica 1869 Indian head cents COPY

 -
 $0.10
 2d 8h 23m
1869 Indian Head Cent

1869 Indian Head Cent

 $59.00 2d 8h 46m
SHARP DETAIL 1869 SHIELD NICKEL

SHARP DETAIL 1869 SHIELD NICKEL

-
 $0.50
 2d 10h 54m
1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT * * VF+ * * VERY RARE

1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT * * VF+ * * VERY RARE

 $255.00 3d 5h 52m
1869, yes 1869 Indian head penny Fine

1869, yes 1869 Indian head penny Fine

 2
 $1.04
 3d 6h 20m
1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT LOW MINTAGE KEY DATE

1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT LOW MINTAGE KEY DATE

 -
 $0.99
 3d 6h 44m
1869 Indian Head Cent G

1869 Indian Head Cent G

 -
 $24.99
 3d 7h 50m
1869 9 Indian Head Cent, Rare Overdate, ANACS AU-53

1869 9 Indian Head Cent, Rare Overdate, ANACS AU-53

 -
 $699.00
$775.00		 3d 8h 21m
1869 9 Indian Head Penny VG ** KEY DATE!!!

1869 9 Indian Head Penny VG ** KEY DATE!!!

6
 $52.00
 3d 8h 31m
3 Scarce Indian Head Cent, All Good, 1869, 1870, 1874

3 Scarce Indian Head Cent, All Good, 1869, 1870, 1874

 -
 $125.00
$135.00		 3d 8h 46m
1869 INDIAN CENT -- VERY FINE (BUT POROUS)

1869 INDIAN CENT -- VERY FINE (BUT POROUS)

 -
 $9.99
 3d 13h 15m
122: 1869 1C PR66 Red NGC.

122: 1869 1C PR66 Red NGC.

 -
 $1.00
 3d 16h 43m
1869 69 INDIAN HEAD CENT ANACS VF20

1869 69 INDIAN HEAD CENT ANACS VF20

 6
 $132.50
 4d 2h 53m
1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT * * * GOOD * * * KEY RARE

1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT * * * GOOD * * * KEY RARE

 $78.00 4d 4h 7m
1869 Indian Head Cent, Sharp Good+, Scarce Date

1869 Indian Head Cent, Sharp Good+, Scarce Date

 -
 $69.00
$75.00		 4d 7h 6m
1869 INDIAN HEAD PENNY CENT TYPE SOLID GOOD + L@@K NR

1869 INDIAN HEAD PENNY CENT TYPE SOLID GOOD + L@@K NR

 1
 $0.99
 4d 8h
1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT GOOD BETTER DATE * LOOK*

1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT GOOD BETTER DATE * LOOK*

 1
 $0.99
 4d 8h 13m
1869 9 Indian Head Cent, Scarce, Sharp VF+, Hole

1869 9 Indian Head Cent, Scarce, Sharp VF+, Hole

 -
 $129.00
 4d 8h 39m
Replica 1869 INDIAN HEAD Cent

Replica 1869 INDIAN HEAD Cent

 -
 $0.10
 4d 8h 42m
1869 9 9 over 9 Variety Indian Cent Circulated Cond

1869 9 9 over 9 Variety Indian Cent Circulated Cond

 3
 $22.50
 4d 9h 2m
1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT VG+

1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT VG+

 1
 $0.99
 4d 9h 14m
1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT FULL RIMS GOOD DETAIL

1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT FULL RIMS GOOD DETAIL

 1
 $49.95
 4d 10h 34m
1869 INDIAN CENT WOW TAKE A PEEK

1869 INDIAN CENT WOW TAKE A PEEK

 -
 $59.95
 4d 16h 28m
Perfect in Every Way! 1867 1868 1869 1870 1871 1872

Perfect in Every Way! 1867 1868 1869 1870 1871 1872

 $60.00 5d 5h 47m
COPY 1869 Indian Head Penny-EXACT

COPY 1869 Indian Head Penny-EXACT

-
 $0.10
 5d 7h 7m
4 Scarce Indian Head Cent,VG to XF,1869,1874,1873,1875

4 Scarce Indian Head Cent,VG to XF,1869,1874,1873,1875

 -
 $185.00
$209.00		 5d 7h 48m
Three Scarce Indian Head Cent,G-VG,1866,1869,1908-S

Three Scarce Indian Head Cent,G-VG,1866,1869,1908-S

 -
 $190.00
$214.00		 5d 8h
7089: 1869 1C AU58 ICG. NGC Census: (32 183). PCGS Popu

7089: 1869 1C AU58 ICG. NGC Census: (32 183). PCGS Popu

 -
 $1.00
 5d 8h 13m
Indian head cent penny 1869 fine vf details scratch

Indian head cent penny 1869 fine vf details scratch

 4
 $10.60
 5d 8h 49m
1869 INDIAN CENT ""GOOD-VG"" KEY DATE CLOSE-OUT C1552

1869 INDIAN CENT ""GOOD-VG"" KEY DATE CLOSE-OUT C1552

 -
 $0.11
 5d 9h 23m
Unsearched Roll of Mixed Cents 1869 Indian on end

Unsearched Roll of Mixed Cents 1869 Indian on end

 3
 $10.60
 5d 9h 47m
PREMIUM 1869 Indian Cent VF to XF ~ RARE!!!

PREMIUM 1869 Indian Cent VF to XF ~ RARE!!!

 -
 $219.95
 5d 20h 51m
Replica 1869 Indian Head Penny-EXACT COPY

Replica 1869 Indian Head Penny-EXACT COPY

 -
 $0.10
 6d 2h 2m
1869 9 9 over 9 Indian Cent G+ Popular Variety

1869 9 9 over 9 Indian Cent G+ Popular Variety

 -
 $9.99
 6d 5h 53m
KEY DATES!!! 1868, 1869, 1872 All G Full Rims

KEY DATES!!! 1868, 1869, 1872 All G Full Rims

 $175.00 6d 6h
Very Nice 1869 Indian Head Cent FREE S H!!

Very Nice 1869 Indian Head Cent FREE S H!!

 -
 $0.99
 6d 7h 31m
1869 Indian Head Penny (No Reserve)

1869 Indian Head Penny (No Reserve)

 -
 $9.99
 6d 7h 42m
Replica 1869 Indian head cents L@@k

Replica 1869 Indian head cents L@@k

 -
 $0.10
 6d 8h 54m
Replica 1869 9 over 9 Indian head cents L@@k

Replica 1869 9 over 9 Indian head cents L@@k

 -
 $0.10
 6d 8h 54m
92274: 1869 RB INDIAN CENT UNCIRCULATED

92274: 1869 RB INDIAN CENT UNCIRCULATED

 -
 $75.00
 6d 10h 43m
92275: 1869 INDIAN CENT MINT STATE KEY DATE

92275: 1869 INDIAN CENT MINT STATE KEY DATE

 -
 $75.00
 6d 10h 43m
1869 INDIAN CENT- RARE KEY DATE- NO RESERVE!!!!

1869 INDIAN CENT- RARE KEY DATE- NO RESERVE!!!!

 -
 $9.95
 7d 1h 30m
1869 Indian Head Cent - G VG

1869 Indian Head Cent - G VG

 1
 $0.99
 7d 8h 19m
1869 69 Indian Head Cent - G

1869 69 Indian Head Cent - G

 -
 $0.99
 7d 8h 20m
1869 Indian Cent PCGS slabbed VF35, nice key date

1869 Indian Cent PCGS slabbed VF35, nice key date

 $379.00 13d 1m
1869 Indian Cent - Nice XF Coin j27-a

1869 Indian Cent - Nice XF Coin j27-a

 $259.99 21d 16h 23m
1869 INDIAN CENT,FULL LIBERTY,NATURAL COLOR,GREAT COIN!

1869 INDIAN CENT,FULL LIBERTY,NATURAL COLOR,GREAT COIN!

 $379.99 22d 2h 40m
1869 9 Indian Cent--Tough Overdate Coin--Good

1869 9 Indian Cent--Tough Overdate Coin--Good

 $85.00 24d 20h 5m
VERY NICE 1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT

VERY NICE 1869 INDIAN HEAD CENT

 $120.00 28d 20m

Sponsored Links