1859 was the 1st year of issue for the indian head penny & the only year the coin did not include the heraldic shield on the reverse of the coin at the top of the wreath.  It had a mintage of 36,400,000 & is much more expensive in higher grades.

Indian Head Penny 1859 Cent Nice XF

Indian Head Penny 1859 Cent Nice XF

 -
 $49.00
$79.00		 3h 15m
1859 INDIAN CENT - ONE YEAR TYPE COIN - PLEASING GOOD

1859 INDIAN CENT - ONE YEAR TYPE COIN - PLEASING GOOD

 3
 $2.75
 3h 16m
1859 INDIAN CENT - ONE YEAR TYPE COIN - PLEASING VG

1859 INDIAN CENT - ONE YEAR TYPE COIN - PLEASING VG

 2
 $3.36
 3h 18m
1859 INDIAN CENT - ONE YEAR TYPE COIN - PLEASING GOOD

1859 INDIAN CENT - ONE YEAR TYPE COIN - PLEASING GOOD

 1
 $0.99
 3h 22m
1859 INDIAN CENT - ONE YEAR TYPE COIN - PLEASING FINE

1859 INDIAN CENT - ONE YEAR TYPE COIN - PLEASING FINE

 2
 $2.25
 3h 25m
1859 Indian Cent

1859 Indian Cent

 -
 $6.75
$9.95		 5h 18m
Antique ! 1859 Indian Head Cent (R3)

Antique ! 1859 Indian Head Cent (R3)

 2
 $9.99
 6h 38m
1859 NCS CERTIFIED INDIAN HEAD NEW STYLE NCS SLAB NR

1859 NCS CERTIFIED INDIAN HEAD NEW STYLE NCS SLAB NR

 $125.00 6h 46m
40 - 1859 INDIAN HEAD CENTS - ONE YEAR TYPE COIN

40 - 1859 INDIAN HEAD CENTS - ONE YEAR TYPE COIN

-
 $199.00
$210.00		 6h 55m
1859 "HARD TO FIND" INDIAN HEAD CENT GRADE "G-4"

1859 "HARD TO FIND" INDIAN HEAD CENT GRADE "G-4"

 -
 $5.00
 7h 10m
SCARCE 1859 Indian Cent CHOICE FINE condition!

SCARCE 1859 Indian Cent CHOICE FINE condition!

 1
 $8.50
 7h 12m
1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT SEMI KEY DATE C N #X20

1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT SEMI KEY DATE C N #X20

 -
 $0.99
 7h 49m
Very Nice 1859 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

Very Nice 1859 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

 2
 $4.00
 8h 12m
Very Nice 1859 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

Very Nice 1859 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

 5
 $4.30
 8h 22m
Very Nice 1859 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

Very Nice 1859 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

 7
 $4.99
 8h 58m
1859, 1860, 1861 INDIAN HEAD CENTS...GREAT COINS!

1859, 1860, 1861 INDIAN HEAD CENTS...GREAT COINS!

 5
 $2.25
 9h 22m
1859 1860 1861 Indian Head Pennies (3) Copper-Nickel

1859 1860 1861 Indian Head Pennies (3) Copper-Nickel

 10
 $14.50
 9h 32m
1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY BRONZE

1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY BRONZE

 -
 $9.98
 9h 58m
1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT C N #Z24

1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT C N #Z24

 -
 $0.99
 23h 53m
1859 Indian Cent vg

1859 Indian Cent vg

 -
 $9.00
$13.00		 1d 1h 19m
1859 Indian Cent : Fine

1859 Indian Cent : Fine

 -
 $0.99
 1d 3h 25m
1859 indian head cent

1859 indian head cent

 -
 $0.99
 1d 5h 2m
1859 Indian Head-- Nice one

1859 Indian Head-- Nice one

 2
 $1.84
 1d 5h 54m
1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT AU+ * * * RARER * * *

1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT AU+ * * * RARER * * *

 $165.00 1d 6h 10m
1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY CENT BETTER COIN REVERSE WREATH

1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY CENT BETTER COIN REVERSE WREATH

 -
 $4.99
 1d 6h 40m
1859 Copper Nickel Indian Head cent 1 year type Fine

1859 Copper Nickel Indian Head cent 1 year type Fine

 -
 $17.95
 1d 7h 16m
Antique ! 1859 Indian Head Cent (D5)

Antique ! 1859 Indian Head Cent (D5)

 -
 $19.99
 1d 8h 45m
1859 Indian Head Penny "Copper-Nickel" CHOICE XF++

1859 Indian Head Penny "Copper-Nickel" CHOICE XF++

 9
 $90.50
 1d 8h 52m
Kasia's Orig Bank Roll Eagles Indians Wheats 1859-Rev

Kasia's Orig Bank Roll Eagles Indians Wheats 1859-Rev

 2
 $10.50
 1d 8h 55m
3 COPPER NICKEL INDIAN HEAD CENTS,. 1859, 1860 & 1863

3 COPPER NICKEL INDIAN HEAD CENTS,. 1859, 1860 & 1863

-
 $9.99
 1d 9h 45m
1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT HI GRADE COUNT ALL THE DIAMONDS!!

1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT HI GRADE COUNT ALL THE DIAMONDS!!

 $115.25 1d 10h 2m
1859 Indian Cent Penny [438]

1859 Indian Cent Penny [438]

 7
 $20.01
 1d 10h 22m
1859 Indian Head Cent VF-XF (Plus Bonus Coin)

1859 Indian Head Cent VF-XF (Plus Bonus Coin)

 3
 $26.55
 1d 12h 31m
1859 Copper Nickel Indian Cent XF

1859 Copper Nickel Indian Cent XF

 2
 $6.05
 1d 22h 38m
1859 1860 1861 1863 1864 COPPER NICKEL CENTS

1859 1860 1861 1863 1864 COPPER NICKEL CENTS

 -
 $35.00
 1d 23h 11m
Lot of 10 1859 Copper Nickel Cents - 1 Year Type Coin

Lot of 10 1859 Copper Nickel Cents - 1 Year Type Coin

 -
 $49.95
$55.00		 2d 1h 29m
1859 Indian penny

1859 Indian penny

 1
 $0.99
 2d 5h 13m
1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY! ANACS EF 45 BEAUTIFUL KEYDATE

1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY! ANACS EF 45 BEAUTIFUL KEYDATE

 3
 $34.33
 2d 5h 26m
1859 Indian Head Small Cent

1859 Indian Head Small Cent

 -
 $0.99
 2d 6h 22m
1859 INDIAN CENT (NICE XF+)

1859 INDIAN CENT (NICE XF+)

 -
 $72.99
 2d 7h 6m
1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT COIN

1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT COIN

 2
 $1.04
 2d 7h 32m
1859 Indian Cent Good A#10

1859 Indian Cent Good A#10

 -
 $0.99
 2d 7h 47m
1859 Indain Head Cent (XF)

1859 Indain Head Cent (XF)

 2
 $1.29
 2d 8h
LOT 39 1859 - 1909 INDIAN HEAD PENNIES 1851 LARGE CENT

LOT 39 1859 - 1909 INDIAN HEAD PENNIES 1851 LARGE CENT

 5
 $27.66
 2d 8h 15m
Very Nice 1859 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

Very Nice 1859 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

 3
 $4.00
 2d 8h 37m
1859 CHOICE VF, ONE YEAR TYPE, INDIAN HEAD CENT

1859 CHOICE VF, ONE YEAR TYPE, INDIAN HEAD CENT

 5
 $9.50
 2d 8h 47m
INDIAN HEAD PENNY 1859 FIRST YEAR ESTATE COLLECTION

INDIAN HEAD PENNY 1859 FIRST YEAR ESTATE COLLECTION

 1
 $0.99
 2d 8h 53m
1859 US Indian head Cent G

1859 US Indian head Cent G

 -
 $0.99
 2d 8h 57m
1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY CENT SMALL COIN REVERSE WREATH

1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY CENT SMALL COIN REVERSE WREATH

 -
 $1.99
 2d 9h 4m
1859 FLYING EAGLE CENT - RARE HIGH GRADE COIN - N R!!!

1859 FLYING EAGLE CENT - RARE HIGH GRADE COIN - N R!!!

 4
 $18.03
 2d 9h 55m
1859 Indian Head Penny - NICE COIN!!!

1859 Indian Head Penny - NICE COIN!!!

 2
 $8.50
 2d 10h 33m
Lot 2 1859 Indian Head Pennies, Very Rough

Lot 2 1859 Indian Head Pennies, Very Rough

 -
 $2.00
 2d 10h 51m
1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT

1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT

 -
 $19.99
 2d 18h 43m
MIXED CENTS 1859 INDIAN HEAD SHOWING.UNSEARCHED

MIXED CENTS 1859 INDIAN HEAD SHOWING.UNSEARCHED

2
 $8.27
 2d 18h 50m
1859 Indian Head Small Cent Old Antique US Coin Money

1859 Indian Head Small Cent Old Antique US Coin Money

-
 $4.99
 2d 23h 34m
1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT C N #Z22

1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT C N #Z22

 -
 $0.99
 2d 23h 48m
1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT C N HAS A DARK SURFACE VG #Z25

1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT C N HAS A DARK SURFACE VG #Z25

 -
 $0.99
 2d 23h 57m
From an Estate: 1859 Indian cent Extra Fine.

From an Estate: 1859 Indian cent Extra Fine.

 1
 $0.99
 3d 15m
1859 Indian head cent GOOD LOOK SEE SCAN

1859 Indian head cent GOOD LOOK SEE SCAN

 -
 $4.99
 3d 5h 51m
1859 Indian head cent semi key date LOOK SEE SCAN

1859 Indian head cent semi key date LOOK SEE SCAN

 -
 $7.99
 3d 6h 27m
1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY CENT BETTER COIN REVERSE WREATH

1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY CENT BETTER COIN REVERSE WREATH

 -
 $5.99
 3d 7h 6m
1859 INDIAN CENT- SCARCE BETTER DATE !! GOOD+ #7209

1859 INDIAN CENT- SCARCE BETTER DATE !! GOOD+ #7209

 -
 $0.99
 3d 8h 42m
2 Copper Nickel Indian Head Cent, 1859 XF+, 1860 AU

2 Copper Nickel Indian Head Cent, 1859 XF+, 1860 AU

 1
 $170.00
 3d 8h 42m
6-PC AG DAMAGED EARLY INDIAN LOT 1859 1863 1864 C N!!

6-PC AG DAMAGED EARLY INDIAN LOT 1859 1863 1864 C N!!

 -
 $19.95
$26.95		 3d 9h 24m
1859 Indian Head Penny NEAR SUPERB GEM BU ** NICE!!!

1859 Indian Head Penny NEAR SUPERB GEM BU ** NICE!!!

11
 $213.61
 3d 9h 58m
1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT nice coin

1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT nice coin

-
 $9.99
 3d 10h 23m
115: 1859 1C PR65 PCGS. CAC.

115: 1859 1C PR65 PCGS. CAC.

 -
 $1.00
 3d 17h 15m
79: 1859 1C MS64 NGC.

79: 1859 1C MS64 NGC.

 -
 $1.00
 3d 17h 15m
1859 Indian Head Penny Dug Civil War Camp

1859 Indian Head Penny Dug Civil War Camp

 -
 $5.99
 3d 22h 8m
1859 COPPER NICKEL CENT FULL STRONG LIBERTY VF XF

1859 COPPER NICKEL CENT FULL STRONG LIBERTY VF XF

 -
 $40.00
$50.00		 3d 23h 16m
Set Copper Nickel Cents 1859-1864

Set Copper Nickel Cents 1859-1864

 -
 $52.00
 4d 35m
1859 indian head C N cent--US cent

1859 indian head C N cent--US cent

 -
 $16.00
 4d 4h 9m
1859 Indian Head Penny Nice Coin! Good Condition!!

1859 Indian Head Penny Nice Coin! Good Condition!!

 -
 $0.99
 4d 5h 44m
1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT VERY FINE.

1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT VERY FINE.

 -
 $9.90
 4d 6h 23m
TEN (10) US INDIAN HEAD PENNIES 1859 thru 1906

TEN (10) US INDIAN HEAD PENNIES 1859 thru 1906

 -
 $12.99
$15.99		 4d 7h 29m
Very Nice 1859 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

Very Nice 1859 Indian Head Cent Nice Coin!!

 3
 $2.50
 4d 8h 7m
1st one ! 1859 Indian Head Cent (L5)

1st one ! 1859 Indian Head Cent (L5)

 -
 $25.99
 4d 8h 12m
3 Copper Nickel Indian Cent, VF-XF, 1859, 1861, 1863

3 Copper Nickel Indian Cent, VF-XF, 1859, 1861, 1863

 -
 $110.00
$125.00		 4d 8h 18m
1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY, Copper-Nickel, 1st year issue

1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY, Copper-Nickel, 1st year issue

 -
 $0.99
 4d 9h 8m
2 High Grade Copper Nickel Cent, 1859 XF, 1862 AU

2 High Grade Copper Nickel Cent, 1859 XF, 1862 AU

 -
 $139.00
$157.00		 4d 9h 26m
1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY NICE FINE COIN

1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY NICE FINE COIN

 -
 $0.99
 4d 10h 19m
1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT FINE OBV. GOOD REV.

1859 INDIAN HEAD CENT FINE OBV. GOOD REV.

 -
 $4.95
 4d 11h 5m
INDIAN CENTS 1859 VG.

INDIAN CENTS 1859 VG.

-
 $11.75
 4d 17h 55m
1859 Copper Nickel Indian Head Small Cent Good, ANA L-M

1859 Copper Nickel Indian Head Small Cent Good, ANA L-M

 -
 $7.75
 5d 1h 44m
1859 Copper Nickel Indian Head Small Cent Very Good ANA

1859 Copper Nickel Indian Head Small Cent Very Good ANA

 -
 $9.75
 5d 1h 44m
* 1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY LIBERTY FULL

* 1859 INDIAN HEAD PENNY LIBERTY FULL

 -
 $0.99
 5d 3h 53m
Nicely Detailed 1859 Indian Cent From Estate

Nicely Detailed 1859 Indian Cent From Estate

 1
 $0.99
 5d 4h 12m
Roll of 50 Indian Head Cents 1859 Top 1880 Bottom

Roll of 50 Indian Head Cents 1859 Top 1880 Bottom

-
 $49.99
 5d 4h 13m
Roll of 50 Indian Head Cents 1859 Top 1883 Bottom